Dimaggio`s Italian Restaurant in Highland

Way too expensive for the quality!

Always great pizza, though a bit pricey. I noticed a "convenience fee" tacked on to my bill, I spent $70 and get a $3 hidden fee added on to my bill, I assume for my credit payment? Buyer beware.

Excellent food! If you are a fan of more traditional style pizza, wings, and pasta, this is your place. Daily lunch buffet is great! Staff is very friendly. This is a family operated business, and it shows. I've been a regular patron for many years, and I've never been never disappointed.

Good pizza! We enjoy coming here to order pizza's to go!

Love the food great people that works therr

What a poor experience and waste of money. We’ve even eaten there before but tonight was a horrible reason to never return. Ended up doing the buffet for the 4 of us (3 over 9 and 1 under - that “includes” your drink) and spent basically $60! Partly because they don’t include milk as a drink but weren’t told till we got the bill - even for kids! The salad was wilted and the wings looked like they had sat there forever and the pasta was sub par at best. Will not be back...ever.

Great food small town atmosphere.

Love the buffet and kids eat free with a adult buffet. Sometimes the buffet has old/cold items.

Fantastic cauliflower pizza crust.

Service was amazing. Lunch buffet was very poor. $10.50 for products that were subpar at best. I found online and drove 30 minutes out of my way off of the interstate.

Great food! Excellent service!

Pasta was mushy, soda tastes like cleaning chemicals, buffet was refilled poorly. Considered going back to try something off the menu but for the price dont think I'll be going back any time soon.

Will visit again, good food and friendly people

Buffet is wonderful, but you can order off a menu if you prefer.

Excellent pizza and great service

Great pizza here, very delicious food. Service was great as well. And they are catering our wedding which is amazing too.

Some of the best pizza in town. The calzones are my family’s favorite. The buffet is equally delicious. The owner is always there and ensures place is in tip top shape. Great place to relax and enjoy some great pizza!

Its pretty good food but expensive.

Place Looks Great. The Garbage Disposal brought me here

Has a good buffet. Have only eaten there at lunch time.

Awesome food and terrific service. Perfect pizza and pasta. The prices are very reasonable. There is a delicious buffet Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday which allows you to try many different kinds of pizza and pasta. There is a nice salad bar and oh yeah hot wings. I highly recommend that this restaurant be placed on your frequent dining stop list. It will quickly become your favorite.

The food is great and the staff is very friendly!

Really nice place, we drive over 30 miles to get there, we like the buffet, they always make you feel like family, the one waitress (L) always knows what we drink and has it ready as soon as we walk in the door. I like the sauce for the pizza, and the pasta, the others like the hot wings.

Not bad but not great.

Highly recommend ! I love their food best pizza I've ever had. Service is great no complaints.

Best pizza in town!

Food was way subpar. Paid 50$for a med pizza. Was supposed to be veggie and it had olives mushrooms and whole uncut grape tomatoes just plopped in top like an after thought. My salad was placed in the same bag as the pasta so lettuce was warm.and cheese was melted in my salad. Cheese bread stick were just that, bread stick with some cheese thrown on it... not going to order there ever again.

Great pizza & love their soup!

Best pizza of all time, I wish I lived closer.

Way over priced and the food is terrible. I would not recommend! Two thumbs down!!

Nice little Italian restaurant near the Square in Downtown Highland. Ordered the Papa Mio Seafood Pasta with Ziti Noodles - excellent. All around good experience. Can"t wait to try again.

Our favorite place in Highland for pizza. Today we tried their sandwiches for the first time. They were quite good. And sides of fries and homemade fries were generous. Shirley made sure we we're well taken care of.

I love DiMaggio's! Joe is the best and the pizza is phenomenal! It really is a family owned and operated restaurant, and the food and service are always exceptional. Their traditional sauce is the best, and their buffalo chicken pizza is to die for. We almost always get the buffet (which they have Tuesday through Sunday for dinner, and Tuesday through Friday for Lunch), but used them to cater a business party and I discovered how good their appetizers were! The new remodel is so beautiful, more space and an updated look. It's a little more of a date night atmosphere but still good for families. You can't find nicer people or better food. Wish I could give them more stars!

Sadly the food does not compare to what Sal served when they first opened. The interior is now dark and depressing. It used to be so Iralian, the closest thing to being in Italy! Unfortunate it totally misses the mark now.

Awesome! Been eating here for years. Never a bad time. Food is always fresh and hot. Try the Chicago style pizza as well. Cocktails, desserts, cold beer, etc....... You can tell the owner cares about his place here. Get you some!

Love the pizza buffet. Great spaghetti

Too expensive for just average pizza. $60 bucks for 4 buffet and 3 soft drinks. We went in on a Friday night at 6pm and the pizza on the buffet had definitely been sitting there for a while...couldn't even eat the crust of the pizza. The pasta had been sitting for a while also. For the same price, we could have had much better pizza at Dewey's or Peel.

DiMaggio's catered my son's wedding rehearsal dinner, their food was on time and fantastic!! I would recommend them to everyone!!! Thank you so much for helping to make it a perfect evening!!

Great food and excellent service!!!

very nice. very crispy really enjoyed it fresh ingredients and they use real mozzarella cheese not provolone or whatever the hell they use at the square beyond despair. actually reminds me of the best pizza I've had in Minneapolis kinda reminds me of the old piper inn

Decent food, but excellent staff and service.

Very good food, very good service.

Nice folks, Good service and GREAT food! Stumbled across them while visiting Highland for volleyball. We always stopped in for a delicious pizza every time we played there. Now the kid is grown and we still make the 40 minute trip each way just for the food. They now have a buffet with pizza, paste, salad, wings (they're awesome) and more! Can't say enough good about them. My drink never sits empty, the staff is very friendly and my belly gets very full. Keep up the good work!

Great wings and buffet

Love this church family!

Nice pizza place. Service was great. Quality of food was okay.

Enjoyed the food and the service.

RUN RUN RUN !!!!!!!!!! “Terrible place have ever been, can't even call a food venue” Unfortunately I have to give at least one star or this one would be -5 I started to write a detailed description of our experience but the memory is too painful to recount. Just do not go into this place however attractive it might look from the outside. Our only regret was that we did not refuse to pay for the dreadful food we were given. We were just happy to get out, learn our lesson and never go back in. Because of the highly commercialised nature of a very busy area, we didn't bother to complain. With hindsight, that was a mistake and one that we will never repeat anywhere else.

Our food took 45 minutes to arrive. Our waitress didn't even offer any apologies until 30 minutes passed. Three others got their food before us even though they arrived after us. Food was mediocre, which was surprising since that wasn't the case before. Kicker was they still charged us full price!

Awesome pizza . Love the mushroom and cheese pizzas .All are good